Topic: Politics, Law and Government / Comparative Politics

 
Comparative History and Legal Theory
Carl Schmitt in the First German Democracy
Jeffrey Seitzer
978-0-31300-067-6

This eBook may be purchased through the following distributors:

 
Jeffrey Seitzer
ADD COPY 2009 ABC-CLIO
Customer Service 800-368-6868

Comparative History and Legal Theory

Carl Schmitt in the First German Democracy

Jeffrey Seitzer Jeffrey Seitzer

May 2001

Praeger

Series: Global Perspectives in History and Politics

Cover
Pages
Volumes
Size
Hardcover
192
1
6 1/8x9 1/4
 
ISBN
eISBN
978-0-313-30792-8
978-0-313-00067-6
Print in Stock
$105.00

add to cart

Critiques Schmitt's comparative-historical state theory.

It is a commonplace of Schmitt scholarship that the controversial thinker sought to recapture some of the elan of the pre-Weimar state through his advocacy of effectively almost unlimited presidential government. Seitzer demonstrates how Schmitt believed comparative history itself could reinvigorate the ailing German state by subtly altering prevailing understandings of the relation of theory and practice in law and politics.

Treating Schmitt's Constitutional Theory and Guardian of the Constitution as methodologically sophisticated comparative histories, Seitzer turns Schmitt's argument against itself. He shows how Schmitt's comparative histories, when properly executed, support a decentralized solution to the Republic's difficulties directly contrary to Schmitt's in terms of its purpose and effect. Problem-oriented, comparative-historical studies of key features of the Weimar system suggest that the dispersion of political power facilitates an institutional dialogue over constitutional principle and practice that better provides for political stability and democratic experimentation. These studies also suggest that linking forms of justification with institutions establishes a productive tension among norms and institutions that is essential to maintaining the viability of constitutional democracy, both in the short- and long-term. This work will be of considerable value to Schmitt scholars and those interested in German legal and political theory as well as those concerned with broad issues in comparative law and European history and political theory.
Introduction
Retrofitting Liberal Constitutionalism: Constitutional Theory as a Response to the Weimar State Crisis
Exorcising the Ghost of Composite States Past: Local Self-Government and Political Stability in the Kaiserreich
Guarding the Constitution: The American Model in German Constitutional Politics
Rethinking the Role of Courts: Constitutional Democracy as Institutional Dialogue
Endorsements
Seitzer's work stands out amidst the recent deluge of scholarship on Carl Schmitt, and it promises to occupy an important position in the intellecutual history of inter-war Germany. At the centre of this work is a sober, discriminating and historically nuanced positioning of Schmitt's constitutional reflections against the practical legal realities of the Weimer Republic. Schmitt's thought emerges from this perspective in a light which is admirably free of demonstrative and polemical gestures. This is likely to add a new dimension to the reception of Schmitt's constitutional theory in the English-speaking world.—Chris Thornhill^LLecturer, Department of German^LKing's College, London

Among the studies that deal with Carl Schmitt the `catholic,' the `theoretician of the Reich, the `decisionist,' among other characterizations, Jeffrey Seitzer presents us in his ^IComparative History and Legal Theory: Carl Schmitt in the First German Democracy^R with an entirely new perspective. Drawing on an impressive knowledge of the Schmitt literature in general and of Schmitt's ^IConstitutional Theory^R and ^IGuardian of Constitution^R in particular, Seitzer brilliantly analyzes Schmitt's use of comparative historical arguments and their normative transformations, in the end developing his own version of democratic politics as institutional dialogue.—Prof. Michael Stolleis^LJ.W. Goethe University^LExecutive Director, Max-Planck Institute for European Legal History





Other Titles Of Interest
Competing Chinese Political Visions Cover ImageCommissions of Inquiry and National Security Cover ImageCold Peace Cover ImageClose Protection Cover ImageCleavages, Parties, and Voters Cover ImageCivil-Military Relations in Post-Communist States Cover ImageCivil Society by Design Cover ImageChina's Energy Strategy Cover ImageBurma's Foreign Relations Cover ImageBuilding an Arsenal Cover ImageBrazil's National Alcohol Program Cover ImageBrazil Cover ImageBetween Bargaining and Politics Cover ImageBerlin Cover ImageAuthoritarianism in Latin America Since Independence Cover ImageAustralia, the Recreational Society Cover ImageAn American Teacher in China Cover ImageAmerican Interests, American Purpose Cover ImageAfrican Democratization and Military Coups Cover ImageAdministrative Reform in Developing Nations Cover ImageA New Century of Corporatism? Cover Image
Competing Chinese Political Visions Cover Image
Competing Chinese Political Visions
Hong Kong vs. Beijing on Democracy

Sonny Shiu-Hing Lo

2010 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $59.95

 

 

Commissions of Inquiry and National Security Cover Image
Commissions of Inquiry and National Security
Comparative Approaches

Stuart Farson and Mark Phythian, Editors

2010 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $59.95

 

 

Cold Peace Cover Image
Cold Peace
Russia's New Imperialism

Janusz Bugajski

2004 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $55.00

 

 

Close Protection Cover Image
Close Protection
The Politics of Guarding Russia's Rulers

David Cox

2000 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $125.00

 

 

Cleavages, Parties, and Voters Cover Image
Cleavages, Parties, and Voters
Studies from Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, and Romania

Kay Lawson, Andrea Rómmele, Georgi Karasimeonov

1999 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $125.00

 

 

Civil-Military Relations in Post-Communist States Cover Image
Civil-Military Relations in Post-Communist States
Central and Eastern Europe in Transition

Anton Bebler

1997 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $106.95

 

 

Civil Society by Design Cover Image
Civil Society by Design
Donors, NGOs, and the Intermestic Development Circle in Bangladesh

Kendall W. Stiles

2002 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $95.00

 

 

China's Energy Strategy Cover Image
China's Energy Strategy
Economic Structure, Technological Choices, and Energy Consumption

Xiannuan Lin

1996 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $125.00

 

 

Burma's Foreign Relations Cover Image
Burma's Foreign Relations
Neutralism in Theory and Practice

Chi-shad Liang

1990 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $106.95

 

 

Building an Arsenal Cover Image
Building an Arsenal
The Evolution of Regional Power Force Structures

Amit Gupta

1997 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $110.95

 

 

Brazil's National Alcohol Program Cover Image
Brazil's National Alcohol Program
Technology and Development in an Authoritarian Regime

F. Joseph Demetrius

1990 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $98.95

 

 

Brazil Cover Image
Brazil
Politics in a Patrimonial Society, Fifth Edition

Riordan Roett

1999 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $125.00

 

 

Between Bargaining and Politics Cover Image
Between Bargaining and Politics
An Introduction to European Labor Relations

Hans Slomp

1996 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $110.95

 

 

Berlin Cover Image
Berlin
From Symbol of Confrontation to Keystone of Stability

James S. Sutterlin, David Klein

1989 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $108.95

 

 

Authoritarianism in Latin America Since Independence Cover Image
Authoritarianism in Latin America Since Independence

Will Fowler

1996 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $115.00

 

 

Australia, the Recreational Society Cover Image
Australia, the Recreational Society

David Mosler

2002 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $86.95

 

 

An American Teacher in China Cover Image
An American Teacher in China
Coping with Cultures

F. A. Kretschmer

1994 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $107.95

 

 

American Interests, American Purpose Cover Image
American Interests, American Purpose
Moral Reasoning and U.S. Foreign Policy

George Weigel

1989 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $82.95

 

 

African Democratization and Military Coups Cover Image
African Democratization and Military Coups

Chuka Onwumechili

1998 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $106.95

 

 

Administrative Reform in Developing Nations Cover Image
Administrative Reform in Developing Nations

Ali Farazmand

2001 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $110.95

 

 

A New Century of Corporatism? Cover Image
A New Century of Corporatism?
Corporatism in Southern Europe--Spain and Portugal in Comparative Perspective

Sebastián Royo

2002 / Praeger

 

Hardcover $110.95